Tregarthen's Hotel

We went to the restaurant. We've been many times over the years. Booked last night for 7pm, ordering pre dinner drinks. We were horribly rushed by the waiting staff. To the extent that plates were cleared whilst were still chewing! We asked for a few minutes break for coffee and petit fours. They came immediately! We asked to go to the lounge area and were finally left in peace. Evidently a shift change as the young waiting staff left about 8pm. No second sitting in the restaurant, it emptied quickly. Just seemed desperate to get people out of tge dining area. It was really disappointing. After many years ( including our honeymoon) won't go again.

We recently returned from a few days on the Scilly isles. We stayed at Tregarthen's for 3 nights, it was our first time staying there, we were not disappointed! The hotel had the most beautiful sea views overlooking the harbour. Our room was beautiful, clean, and modern. The service was amazing, well done to all of the staff there, they all went above and beyond, nothing was too much trouble for them. The hotel was clean and had a lovely relaxing vibe. We were only planning to eat in the restaurant one evening, after the first dinner we ended up eating there every night, it was delicious. Breakfast was plentiful, hot and tasty. We have already booked again for next year.

Stayed here on our visit to St Marys. Was right by the main dock so not far to walk. As most other had commented this hotel does have steps (though there is a slope by the main enterence) We stayed in room 63 which was lovely and had a small seaview. I did enjoy sitting by the window watching the sea. I would recommend this room for 2 people. We had a small wardobe then a chest of draws, plenty of storage for us and our soft bags (could see if you had a hard suitcase storage would be limited) . The only slight downside was the bathroom was a little dated. You had to pre book your breakfast time at the start which was fine and worked out well for us. Breakfast choice was good and the chef was able to make simple scrambed eggs by the selves or a combo of other items on the menu. The room was cleaned every day and got fresh water. Location wise it's was perfect and we would stay here again. Although the hotel was full it never felt like that. There were dogs there when we stayed but it wasn't an issue for us. A few evenings we went back and enjoyed a drink on the patio/ lounge area. On our departure the hotel booked our tranfser back to the airport which was great.

Lovely to get off the Scillonian and walk straight into our harbour side hotel! Stayed in their new lodges which were perfect with splendid views of the bay and harbour. Solid cooked breakfast from menu accompanied by a range of continental options. Pecan slices were a favourite! Staff were delightful and friendly.

Had an excellent week's stay here. Stayed in a superior sea view room - the view across the harbour/quay was amazing. Room was clean and comfortable. Breakfast every morning was great - a buffet available plus cooked breakfast options to order. We also had an evening meal and a Sunday dinner there and both were excellent. All the staff were helpful and friendly. Overall a great experience, very enjoyable!

We had a lovely room with a double aspect sea view room. The hotel was very relaxed and welcoming and the staff very attentive. The position was perfect as it was only a few minutes walk to the ferries. Plenty of outside and inside areas to sit and relax. Would certainly recommend.