Sunset Key Cottages

Jazzy elevates the meaning of welcome to the island….always a big smile coupled with laughter….knowing everyone’s name…on his day off brought my wife balloons and serenaded her at dinner….all a surprise!!!….he is such an asset to the island and is everyone’s rock star....he is the BEST

Our family of six had the pleasure of staying at the cottages, and from the moment we arrived, we felt completely at ease. This resort truly is a sanctuary—thoughtfully designed, warmly staffed, and full of small touches that made a big impact on our stay. Traveling with four energetic, school-aged boys isn’t always easy, but the entire team welcomed us with open arms. They were ready for anything and met every moment with kindness and care. When airline delays disrupted our arrival, Andre and Leah stepped in without hesitation, ensuring our plans stayed intact and our experience was seamless from the start. We’re so grateful for their flexibility and support. Every day brought new delights—from morning and evening deliveries of snacks, water, and sweets to the joy our kids found in daily poolside activities with the incredible Ms. Sarah. The attention to detail here is remarkable, and the hospitality is as genuine as it gets. The cottages themselves are spotless, beautifully appointed, and ideal for families. Spacious, comfortable, and well-equipped—they felt like a home away from home. We left with full hearts and a longing to return. If you’re considering a stay, don’t hesitate. Pack your bags—you’re going to love it.

Sarah is as exceptional with the kids and they had a fantastic time in the pool with a lot of activities. It was fun for the kids to have some games with the other kids and they had a great time. They even gave a free kids drink to the winner. They were very excited.

Sarah did a fantastic job running a fun pool activity for our kids! We enjoyed seeing all the kids play together so nicely. I would highly recommend this resort to anyone looking to bring their family. The level of engagement was greatly appreciated

Sunset Key is amazing. The food, the beach and the pool were perfect. Finesse Experience with Sarah was great. My kids loved it. Gave us some time to relax and enjoy the sun. She entertained the kids for an hour. The staff and service was top notch.

From the moment we arrived to the ferry at Opal, we knew we made the right choice with Sunset Key. The level of professionalism of the entire crew, the quality of the grounds and cottages, and just the overall vibes of the resort are impeccable. We stayed in the Driftwood cottage and couldn’t have been happier with the location - we had a partial ocean view and close proximity to beach, pool, and clubhouse. Nigel planned an excursion for us one day and we had a blast. If you want to have fun in Key West but have a quiet, relaxing spot to rest and relax this is the spot. We will be back!